Rave Adelaide A fan archive of the forums, 2003–2008

Forums › Insight

LPG - Pros & Cons

Earliest surviving post 15 Jun 2006 · 30 of about 39 posts survive · look for it on the Wayback Machine

LPG - Pros & Cons, on for the rev heads
SpadgePosted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:12pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
QUOTE(-strobe- @ Jun 15 2006, 02:05 PM)
lpg gets you around good enough, but i prefer the power of petrol!
*


see this is where i am different
i prefer the extra dollars in my pocket rather than a bit of extra power

im still leaning towards getting a gas system put on my car
no matter what i try and find for a reason not to do it, it will work out cheaper in the long run theres no doubt about it
alexb618Posted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:14pm
the tour wooooGroup: Members
Posts: 5,908
Joined: 30-November 03
spade if youve had the car a while it might work out better to sell it and get a car with gas already on it

stamp duty would be the killer though
BettermanPosted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:22pm
FUCK HISTORY!!!!!!!Group: Members
Posts: 6,909
Joined: 10-January 05
From: the ghetto
spadge also remember that you should only get it if you are planning on keeping your car a few years. i worked it out wiht my old car, conversion cost me $1300 (was a carby v8 not fuel injected), an i worked out at the average price of gas then (35c) it would take me a good year of driving x amount of kms to get the money back. today with the higher gas price and more expensive conversions for fuel injected cars, it will take longer, prob closer to 2 years.

one other thing im not happy with, is the way the government keeps the cost of gas propotional to the price of petrol! its fkn gay! just coz fuel goes up doesnt mean gas should. it is a hell cheap to make product and should always be in the 30c a litre range. gone are the days when i would fill up my tank with less than $20
wojtekPosted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:31pm
Can I touch your hram?Group: Admin
Posts: 8,909
Joined: 28-October 03
To be honest i dont notice much of a performance difference between LPG and Petrol (VS 6), not that I fang it often, if at all.

It gets about 330-350k out of ~50 lt of gas, the only problems I've had with the gas is backfiring but changing the gap on the plugs fixed it. Actually had more problems with the fuel system than the gas, dead pump x2, dirty injectors etc etc.
alexb618Posted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:40pm
the tour wooooGroup: Members
Posts: 5,908
Joined: 30-November 03
QUOTE(wojtek @ Jun 15 2006, 04:31 PM)
To be honest i dont notice much of a performance difference between LPG and Petrol (VS 6), not that I fang it often, if at all.

It gets about 330-350k out of ~50 lt of gas, the only problems I've had with the gas is backfiring but changing the gap on the plugs fixed it. Actually had more problems with the fuel system than the gas, dead pump x2, dirty injectors etc etc.
*



wouldnt that be because you are not running much petrol through it though?
wojtekPosted: 15 Jun 2006, 4:51pm
Can I touch your hram?Group: Admin
Posts: 8,909
Joined: 28-October 03
Could be, we go through a 1/3 of a tank per month on average, just following what the sticker says ;)
SpadgePosted: 16 Jun 2006, 11:31pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
QUOTE(alexb618 @ Jun 15 2006, 04:14 PM)
spade if youve had the car a while it might work out better to sell it and get a car with gas already on it

stamp duty would be the killer though
*


mate i bought the car a month ago

i was looking for a similar car on gas and they werent easy to find, and the ones i did had done 200+ thousand K's and i wasnt interested in a car that had done that many Ks

i decided to bite the bullet and buy a car which has under 100 thousand on the clock and just get it converted

and yes i do plan to keep this car for a few years.. probably more
DimitriPosted: 16 Jun 2006, 11:41pm
A MuppetGroup: Members
Joined: 31-October 03
From: 5008
QUOTE(Betterman @ Jun 14 2006, 05:00 PM)
look after the car, get the gas system checked every time its due,

*




LOL he didnt get the shopping trolly serviced for like 7 years or something???

haha
SpadgePosted: 16 Jun 2006, 11:43pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
QUOTE(Dimitri @ Jun 16 2006, 11:41 PM)
LOL he didnt get the shopping trolly serviced for like 7 years or something???

incorrect i got the daepoo serviced all the time when it was needed in the first 5 years, and then probably once a year after that which was a bit slack...but still... your 7 years is just bull

plus the missus wont let me neglect this car
i value my balls too much
SoftyPosted: 16 Jun 2006, 11:49pm
Annoying WankerGroup: Members
Posts: 1,568
Joined: 14-June 04
From: Adelaide
i never been a fan of LPG/Petrol combos. but on something like a VX u wont have many problems. comapred to some old clapped out vn or something.


just make sure u go to a decent place that does the conversions,not some cheap back yard dude.

if it was me i would be finding out who does the majority of the Goverment and taxi commodores and go there.

they would know the conversion inside and out.
DimitriPosted: 16 Jun 2006, 11:49pm
A MuppetGroup: Members
Joined: 31-October 03
From: 5008
QUOTE(Spadge @ Jun 16 2006, 11:43 PM)
incorrect i got the daepoo serviced all the time when it was needed in the first 5 years, and then probably once a year after that which was a bit slack...but still... your 7 years is just bull

plus the missus wont let me neglect this car
i value my balls too much
*



just going on what stek said, blame him
SpadgePosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:15pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
ok well my boss decided to call the RAA for me when i was away for a couple of days last week to find out about whether it was worth me getting a conversion

apparently he was told that its not recommended to get a VX put on gas, and pretty much the same with any car with aluminium heads due to valve seats recessing
also said about backfiring being a problem

reckons it could cause head problems and possibly could cost a couple of grand to fix

he also told my boss that if i did decide to go for gas anyway that i would need to go for a system which was direct gas injection which costs around $3000-$3500..

now my boss has taken this as gospel and reckons i'd be a dick to get gas put on.....

harry? anyone else?

i really want to put gas on but i dont really want to run into probs down the track and theres no fucking way im spending 3 grand on a system
LasermadPosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:29pm
Safe as Fuck !Group: Members
Posts: 606
Joined: 30-December 03
From: Adelaide Hills
I know stuff all about VX commodores but I ran an XE falcon on LPG for years without even servicing it other than the occasional oil change and I never had a problem, or so much as a backfire.

It's noticeably cheaper to run, and the power difference isn't noticeable unless you're pulling a caravan or trying to flog someone off the line.

I've still got the car and the gas system I could flog you for stuff all if its of any use to you, it wasn't an E.F.I vehicle tho so i'd be surprised if you could use the whole gas setup.. tank is fine tho ;)

I payed $500 to get the gas system put in, as the tank/parts came with the car when I bought it but wasn't installed so I only had to pay for the conversion.. if you can hook up a similar arrangement and you just need the tank etc then maybe it would be of use. It took about 65 litres from memory, dual fuel switch and LED LPG gauge under the dash.

Pity you can't run ricers on lpg, I miss that lpg price tag ! 30c a litre used to be considered expensive.
slidePosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:42pm
u smellGroup: Moderator
Posts: 8,748
Joined: 17-January 05
From: inside you
softy - nail on head..

they may be factory jobs though with different valves etc.

call Holden Steve... may even be able to get it done there.

dont go the cheapest option - u will ALWAYS pay for wat you get.
SpadgePosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:48pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
$2000-$2500 im keen... over that im not keen at all
i'll ring the RAA myself and holden... but im asking around for those who have had conversions done as well
metal head!Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:48pm
BUDA BING! exclusive.soprano!Group: Members
Posts: 5,688
Joined: 5-November 03
From: your mums house
spadge!
come down to my work anytime and i will take you to the GURU of gas my mate hugo.
he has been doin it for over 20 years has records for the fastest gas car in australia.
does goventment cars
cops cars
taxis.

save yourself the headfucks and listning to wankers come and see me.

end of story option is there for you.
BettermanPosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:51pm
FUCK HISTORY!!!!!!!Group: Members
Posts: 6,909
Joined: 10-January 05
From: the ghetto
QUOTE(Spadge @ Jun 20 2006, 05:15 PM)
ok well my boss decided to call the RAA for me when i was away for a couple of days last week to find out about whether it was worth me getting a conversion

apparently he was told that its not recommended to get a VX put on gas, and pretty much the same with any car with aluminium heads due to valve seats recessing
also said about backfiring being a problem

reckons it could cause head problems and possibly could cost a couple of grand to fix

he also told my boss that if i did decide to go for gas anyway that i would need to go for a system which was direct gas injection which costs around $3000-$3500..

now my boss has taken this as gospel and reckons i'd be a dick to get gas put on.....

harry? anyone else?

i really want to put gas on but i dont really want to run into probs down the track and theres no fucking way im spending 3 grand on a system
*


the amount a car on gas backfires all has to do wtih the tuning of the gas system. if it is tuned correctly it wont backfire. mine needs a good tune so it sometimes does small little 'spit' backfires when i lay off the throttle, not massive ones though but when i take it in for its next tune that will fix it. ps - i love my car when it does those little backfires, sounds like a v8supercar ;)

as for the seals, everyone says to be careful of that and you should change them to suit lpg etc etc but ive never encountered an issue. even so, ive posted ur question on another board i go on sometimes (street commodores) to ask the experts there, il post up any reponses they give....
SpadgePosted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:53pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
i was talking valve seats harry not seals

and jimbo might take you up on that offer
alexb618Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:53pm
the tour wooooGroup: Members
Posts: 5,908
Joined: 30-November 03
QUOTE(Spadge @ Jun 20 2006, 04:15 PM)
apparently he was told that its not recommended to get a VX put on gas, and pretty much the same with any car with aluminium heads due to valve seats recessing
*



ask him how many production cars in 2006 come with a cast iron head

you will be fine on gas if you see the right people

go speak to jimbo
metal head!Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 4:58pm
BUDA BING! exclusive.soprano!Group: Members
Posts: 5,688
Joined: 5-November 03
From: your mums house
good point alex

i,d say NO CAR comes out with a cast iron head things of the 70,s and 80s maybe early 90s

on the valve seats they are ususally hardened steal inserts anyway. which you replace when you recon heads. NOT in the lifetime of your car mate.
unless your unlucky and have to do it BUT i would say you would get atleast 150,000 out of it before then.

and by then you would be trading up anyway. :)

This post has been edited by metal head!: Jun 20 2006, 05:02 PM
SpadgePosted: 20 Jun 2006, 5:03pm
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
QUOTE(alexb618 @ Jun 20 2006, 04:53 PM)
ask him how many production cars in 2006 come with a cast iron head
*


your right... but then they say the newer cars which have gas factory fitted come with hardened valve seats
metal head!Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 5:08pm
BUDA BING! exclusive.soprano!Group: Members
Posts: 5,688
Joined: 5-November 03
From: your mums house
i dont believe that mate you telling me that they get the motors and pull them apart just to put hardened valve seats in? sounds like crap to me.

+ i couldnt see them stopping a production line and changing a machine just to fit hardened valve seats.

I COULD BE WRONG........... BUT USUALLY NOT! (modest eh)
metal head!Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 5:10pm
BUDA BING! exclusive.soprano!Group: Members
Posts: 5,688
Joined: 5-November 03
From: your mums house
just come see me whenever you want hes in the same street as me i,ll ask him in a minute when i go past if hes there and post up what he says after 6pm.
alexb618Posted: 20 Jun 2006, 5:23pm
the tour wooooGroup: Members
Posts: 5,908
Joined: 30-November 03
QUOTE(Spadge @ Jun 20 2006, 05:03 PM)
your right... but then they say the newer cars which have gas factory fitted come with hardened valve seats
*



mate i woudl be honestly surprised to see which late model cars dont come with hardened valve seats anyway, considering they are almost a mandatory requirement for running unleaded fuel
MaydayPosted: 20 Jun 2006, 5:33pm
No Guus, no glory!Group: Moderator
Posts: 10,620
Joined: 1-November 03
From: Back Home!
Its much easier for a manufacturer to make all cars with something like hardened valve seats rather than having it as an option on some of them.
BettermanPosted: 21 Jun 2006, 8:55am
FUCK HISTORY!!!!!!!Group: Members
Posts: 6,909
Joined: 10-January 05
From: the ghetto
QUOTE(alexb618 @ Jun 20 2006, 06:23 PM)
mate i woudl be honestly surprised to see which late model cars dont come with hardened valve seats anyway, considering they are almost a mandatory requirement for running unleaded fuel
*


exactly

also ecotec V6's (incl VX) are a 100 % cast iron motor (block and heads)

got reply from commodore forum. You DEFINATELY dont need gas injection, however it is better than gas carbie/s, and can support more power, however the gas mixers work quite fine, which is what i have on my current and old car. direct gas injection just gives you better throttle response and power.

SpadgePosted: 21 Jun 2006, 9:10am
The Mighty Port Magpies!!Group: Admin
Posts: 15,789
Joined: 28-October 03
From: Adelaide, South Australia
so basically everyone is saying this guy from the RAA is full of shit

thanks for all your help and advice guys
its much appreciated

i also asked the same thing on a different commodore forum and they pretty much said the same thing although one guy said to combat valve seat recessing he had a flashlube kit installed

what the fucks a flashlube kit and what does it cost and is it needed
wojtekPosted: 21 Jun 2006, 9:24am
Can I touch your hram?Group: Admin
Posts: 8,909
Joined: 28-October 03
QUOTE(Betterman @ Jun 21 2006, 08:55 AM)
direct gas injection just gives you better throttle response and power.
*



So i'm not on crack... it does 'lag' when its on LPG.
Harry, when yours backfires does it dislodge hoses/blow airbox?
My airbox is missing 1/2 of its clips from when the car went through its backfiring stage.
BettermanPosted: 21 Jun 2006, 9:31am
FUCK HISTORY!!!!!!!Group: Members
Posts: 6,909
Joined: 10-January 05
From: the ghetto
flash lube is the stuff u can buy to keep lubrication levels up for cars running lrp and want to run unleaded, or for lpg applications too

think most servos sell em for about $3 which is enough to use with 1 tank of fuel. but its definately not needed, I hav enever used it with my new car and most ppl i know that run lpg dont use it. Supposidly lubricates valves etc and keeps the top of the engine clean.

Sometimes I flash lube on my VH SLE V8 tho. which was running duel fuel.

This post has been edited by Betterman: Jun 21 2006, 09:50 AM
BettermanPosted: 21 Jun 2006, 9:35am
FUCK HISTORY!!!!!!!Group: Members
Posts: 6,909
Joined: 10-January 05
From: the ghetto
QUOTE(wojtek @ Jun 21 2006, 10:24 AM)
So i'm not on crack... it does 'lag' when its on LPG.
Harry, when yours backfires does it dislodge hoses/blow airbox?
My airbox is missing 1/2 of its clips from when the car went through its backfiring stage.
*


:lol: yes i have blown my airbox once! blew a hole right in the front (mostly due to the backfire which is due to gas mixtures needing tuning)

what you can do to counter this though is, instead of securing the top of your airbox with screws etc, use those short elastic ropes with hooks on either end, you know the ones im talkin about? you can get them in different lengths so you get a couple short ones. so you attatch the airbox top with em so when you get a backfire the airbox blows up but not off :lol:

i dont have them on mine i guess il wait to see if i blow another airbox this year lmao